This site is the successor to the Second Renaissance website. Why the new name

PodcastThe Field Between UsPart 2 of 4

How Eleven Women Broke Through Separation

Humiliation reinforces the self. Curiosity opens the field.

Series intro

This is part of a four-part series with Elizabeth Debold on interbeing and emergent dialogue.

Elizabeth Debold, Ed.D., came to the late Andrew Cohen's EnlightenNext community at forty with a Harvard doctorate and a bestselling book, and found something none of it had prepared her for: a field of shared awareness that opened between eleven women on a retreat in 1999, then between thirty men in 2001. She was thrown out five times and kept going back. When the community collapsed she and her partner Thomas Steininger, who died in 2025, spent the years since asking what that field was and how to cultivate it without a guru. Four conversations with Rufus Pollock: the story, the practice, the ideas, and where it could lead.

This episode

Eleven women talking until a window came down. What a collective awakening is made of, and why humiliation can’t produce it.

Rufus asks what practices produced the 1999 breakthrough. Elizabeth’s answer: the context was dialogue, though nobody named it then. Cohen, she says, saw people coming together in a field of inquiry and love, didn’t know how to get there, and pounded on people’s ego structures instead. What were the eleven women doing when it happened? Talking. They described the thing that cut them off when they met, someone called it an electric car window, they all recognised it at the same instant and burst out laughing, and the windows were down. “A landing home together. There was unspeakable joy.” You become more yourself, not less.

It was a liberation into each other. Not an individualistic liberation. It was like a landing home together.

She explains why humiliation fails on its own terms: you push someone into separation, then accuse them of being separate. What works is sincere curiosity about what is possible between people, and care for what shows up. Then Germany: Thomas Steininger’s Tuesday night meditation and dialogue, kept going for twenty or twenty-five years and across the collapse. “I had absolutely no doubt.” Why they dropped the word enlightenment. What a newcomer feels first (warm water, tenderness) and why that is baby step one. She ends with a tense meeting about money where a consultant asked “What if you started fresh?” and something opened.

The caterpillar knows nothing of the butterfly it will become.

Chapters

  • 00:00Background practices: the world we keep making
  • 05:54Cohen's mistake: an individual awakening
  • 12:43The five tenets, and who they are about
  • 16:05Eleven women, an electric car window, laughter
  • 21:19You become more yourself
  • 23:46Why humiliation reinforces separation
  • 31:32Germany: Tuesday nights, Thomas, no doubt
  • 45:23"I would never do that, Elizabeth." "You did."
  • 48:05Dropping the word enlightenment
  • 51:46Warm water, then the wind: what interbeing is
  • 1:00:10"What if you started fresh?" A meeting opens
  • 1:06:48Holding a tension that won't resolve

Speakers

Elizabeth Debold, Ed.D., is a gender researcher, writer, and teacher who has spent four decades asking how women and men can grow toward freedom and equality together. She was a founding member of the Harvard Project on Women’s Psychology and Girls’ Development, co-wrote the bestseller Mother Daughter Revolution, and co-founded One World in Dialogue, a global network of people practicing deep dialogue.

Rufus Pollock is a co-founder of Life Itself, an entrepreneur, activist, and author, as well as a long-term zen practitioner.

Transcript

Rufus Pollock (00:14) So welcome back, Elizabeth. This is the second episode in a series with you exploring your work with Thomas Steininger and many others in the practice of emergent dialogue and exploring the idea of interbeing and a kind of a new kind of collective awakening that we is desperately needed at this time. And at the end of the last the first episode, we were talking about what had happened in the EnlightenNext community, that there had been this kind of collective awakening experience, and then the breakdown of that community, and you then moved to Germany. Can you say in your book, which you’re I know you’re working on, you talk a little bit about the a little bit of context about what was also happening with Andrew Cohen and what you saw happening and which was also informing what you were then thinking about, which is This idea from Dreyfus and Kelly, I think in your book, of reconfiguration. and can you can you say a bit about that?

Elizabeth Debold (01:26) Yeah, I mean the point that I’m making is that Cohen was somewhat of a reconfigurator. And a reconfigurator according to Hubert Dreyfus who’s a hi was he passed a few years ago, a Heideggerian philosopher. but has also done a lot of work with Foucault and Merleau-Ponty and everybody else in the in the pantheon of deconstructed deconstructivists, embodiment, interesting philosophers of the 20th century. But he speaks about points in time where what we think of as human, what we think of as important, what it means to be here, changes. And that is so he says, first of all there are one has to become aware that there are what he calls background practices. Background practices that create the world as it is. We don’t think of what we’re doing in being individuals, in having separation be such a large so foundational to how we understand life. That I’m an individual, that things are separate, that they move more mechanistically, cause and effect, or kind of billiard ball cause and effect, that what else? I mean it all starts with separation. And that’s something that I’d like us like us to talk about today, which is the subject-object distinction.

Rufus Pollock (03:26) Mm-hmm.

Elizabeth Debold (03:28) But that everything is separate and in and each of us is separate and we try to find other folks to hang on to and create a little bit of a lifeboat for ourselves because yeah we’re we’re taught that we’re at home alone in a in a in a in a cold, indifferent cosmos. So what Dreyfus is pointing to is that worldview is a set of practices, that we’re actually practicing this. And at one point there was there were transitions that marked key steps in that in that the development of those practices, the ways of thinking and seeing that the that create this world, that are the practices that we’re engaging with. But he said, so the first thing in a reconfiguration is to recognize that there are background practices that create the world as it is. And that a reconfigurator comes along and starts to express something that is very difficult for people to understand because it’s outside of the background practices that they do and that they’re familiar with. And a wonderful example of this is the difference between the Roman vision of life. and what made life worthwhile, which was power. and the early Christians, you know, in terms of their surrender to God, their embracing of celibacy, which the Romans really thought was nuts. and so on. It it’s like the transit the transition is something that is that is difficult because it’s not understood what is it that we’re being called to do because it’s so outside the boundaries of what is known and understood.

Rufus Pollock (05:52) Hmm.

Elizabeth Debold (05:54) And I feel I saw that in the Cohen community, that there was a that there was ongoingly and in some ways this was I would say a mistake of Andrew Cohen himself. that things were interpreted in an individual way, like my enlightenment or my ego, a sense that this experience of opening or what we would we would say emergence of a of a different of a different consciousness was actually an individual affair. And it’s actually quite subtle. It’s very subtle. It it’s to really put the phenomenon that is happening collectively in the forefront of your understanding rather than speaking about groups of individuals having an opening or you know, or individuals having this experience. It’s tr that’s true, but there’s a way in which reinforcing the individual keeps us in the old framework. And I would say that I make this mistake because it’s such a deep habit, it’s such a deep practice, you could say, of individualism. and we haven’t We haven’t begun to kind of revision the world from the reality of a living field that opens between us when we’re when we’re curious, available, and leaning in.

Rufus Pollock (07:59) And so if I recap this, so one that Dreyfus is pointing out is that our worldview, so for example, this assumption of individuals, which maybe some people listen to the podcast, well of course they’re individuals, but part of what we say is no, these things are kind of created in some sense, this way of seeing the world. But in there are practices that we perform, ways of speaking, of acting, that kind of constantly reinforce the dominant the default worldview that normally people are in a culture. And then what comes

Elizabeth Debold (08:31) Right.

Rufus Pollock (08:31) along, and I’m quoting here what you’re quoting in your work, you actually quote Dreyfus and Kelly and you say the reconfigurer would introduce new practices and a new method that transform people’s understanding of themselves and their world by showing a really new way of life. And then between this is in you speaking, you’re saying between nineteen ninety nine and two thousand one Different groups of students broke through separation and were lifted into a shared field of awareness that was nothing short of ecstatically explosive. And in nineteen ninety nine, you, Elizabeth, were part of a group of eleven women who had a first breakthrough and the access to the state last a few days. So I’d love to know, first of all, I mean you could say more about what actually happened. I know you talked a bit in the last episode, but also what were the kind of practices? Whether they were whether some of them you would even I know you then evolved many of them. But what kind of practices that were being introduced that you think were contributing to this kind of breakthrough, even if they were maybe not seen till later as to what they were?

Elizabeth Debold (09:35) Well I think that’s part of what’s interesting because The context was dialogue but that was sort of an unacknowledged that it was dialogue. I mean this was this was the trouble with I mean I think I said last time that I felt that a that Andrew Cohen was actually a quite a poor teacher. And I mean he had a dilemma, which is he had a of vision and he saw people coming together in a in a field of mutual inquiry and curiosity and intelligence and love. He saw that, but he didn’t know how to get from here to there. So what he did was he basically said he said, okay, so it’s the structures of yourself that are the problem. the structures of the human self that are that are the problem. We are we have practices of being in individual. He’s not saying what they are. Like it wasn’t simply self-referencing like saying, well I think this or I think that or I feel this way. I it it’s not simply that, although that might be part of it. But he didn’t know how to get from here to there. So he would just pound on people’s ego structures, finding ways that finding the points where they were as we all are, deeply identified with self, and then just really smashing on that. And those are not practices, I wouldn’t say. and in fact that kind what we began when by when I say we, I mean primarily Thomas Steininger and myself focused on was was the sensing of the field and allowing the care that emerges naturally when this when this field awareness becomes aware of itself. when we’re open to this the this dimension between us, curious about it, and as it becomes aware of itself through us, what it emerges in us is a love and care for it.

Rufus Pollock (12:31) But what kind of practices that were being introduced that you think were contributing to this kind of breakthrough, even if they were maybe not seen till later as to what they were?

Elizabeth Debold (12:43) Okay, so I think I mean Andrew would say it was following his five tenets, the five tenets of his teaching.

Rufus Pollock (12:55) Which will work?

Elizabeth Debold (12:57) let’s see if I can remember them. so the first one is clarity of intention, having a an intention to want to be free more than anything else. the second is the law of volitionality, that everything that you do is came from your own will to do it. And also that the that the whatever the effect of what you have created creates that you’re responsible for that. That’s part of your volition. The third is I think face everything and avoid nothing. And the next one is the truth of impersonality, that the human experience is one and that it’s shared. It’s not the world of feeling and thought and so forth is not something that is yours alone or special to you, but but it’s what human is. And the last is care for the whole which he always said and I won’t explain that because you can’t understand it. But if you notice all of these refer to the individual. All of these are about the individual and In some ways they’re talking about deeper aspects of self, like clarity of intention. But clarity of intention is wanting to be free more than anything else. That’s an individual a aspiration that says nothing about collective emergence. And these Our breakthrough through the Eleven Women was through a deep dive into the truth of impersonality, which I’ve always found to be because that’s one of the one of the few of the tenets that actually that and care for the whole, that actually focuses on something collective. Because when you have a you have people who all recognize that there is there that they are different expressions of the same human condition. You have a powerful gr collective ground to work from. But the most of the other and care for the whole is also some It it’s about something beyond and encompassing of selves rather than the self.

Rufus Pollock (16:05) So tell me, so you just said when it was the eleven women, you were doing something, you were practicing, you were there was a deep dive, you said, into

Elizabeth Debold (16:14) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (16:14) the truth of human personality. So just what were you meditating what was happening? We were talking.

Elizabeth Debold (16:19) No, no, we were talking. It was we were talking. We were talking, we were we were sharing our experience of Of separation. We were sharing our experience. There was something that we that we saw got in the way of our being able to be fully present. And it we likened it to I think someone said this, it may have been me, that it that there was something that happened when we were brought when we when we came together that felt like An electric car window. that you that in coming together that there would be this reaction that would be like cut off and you would find yourself behind this kind of glass space or this a kind of rupture in the in the in the fabric of togetherness. And we all we had a moment where we all instantaneously at the same time recognized this was this was our experience. And something we burst out laughing. And in that in that recognition amongst the group, that same recognition, that non-separateness right there, something broke through. and it became the windows were down, we things were broken open and yeah. I spoke about this I think a bit the last time. But this is more more detail. But that and that

Rufus Pollock (18:26) What was it what was it like? Can you give even a taste of

Elizabeth Debold (18:32) it was it was a profound liberation. It was a liberation a liberation into each other in a kind of sense. Not a not an individualistic liberation, but it was it was It was like a landing, a landing home together. It’s I would say it’s sort of like coming into the into Oz or something, you know, that there was There was unspeakable joy. and a sense of a sense of care for each other. but not in not in this kind of individualistic way, like, honey, I care about you. But in a in a way that transcend transcended oneself and transcended the group.

Rufus Pollock (19:41) And you say this kind of field of intelligence and wisdom was open between participants that transformed the boundaries of self and revealed the relatedness and non separation that exists before our difference. And what you say is that I mean you as one and another of Cohen’s students began to set up the guidelines for this practice you called in at that time enlightened communication.

Elizabeth Debold (20:05) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (20:06) this vibrant field of inquiry. And can you say something? ‘Cause I think You say here this last thing, a vibrant field of inquiry into the experience of diversity in unity that occurred between participants. And for a short period in settings within and outside the organization, this form of dialogue was intrinsic to the life of the community. So one of the things that I really maybe I want to come back to with this well, maybe you talk about it now, but this diversity in unity. I’ll lose myself in a in a like in the way that we someone’s doing the madness of crowds, which can also be elated. And I think also people are even scared of like, is it does this is this the Nuremberg rally or something like that? Are we losing ourselves? And it’s not, right? You’ve said this very clearly, it’s a diversity that this we’re st it’s still there. It we want to say rather, I is still there, but there’s a larger field that has emerged or that’s you discovered that’s always been there. Can you say a little bit about that? Maybe again concrete, like what was it? actually like when you’re there with these women, what Elizab you know, what we think of normally as Elizabeth of our the ego, mind or the self, what did

Elizabeth Debold (21:19) Well what what’s interesting is that you become more yourself. And

Rufus Pollock (21:24) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (21:25) that’s part of part of so the essence of this intelligence is that it resolves paradoxes that have been created by the modern mind. So self other, mind body. male fem not male female but masculine feminine that these polarities that have defined modernity and are essential to modernity and how we think end up finding their way you have a lived sense of resolution with them so you become More yourself and more relaxed in into an immanence, a sense of being at home, of belonging, while you feel also more uniquely you. So this sense of uniqueness of your own experience is deepened as you also recognize and experience the non-separation between you and others. It’s like out of this field of non-separation or this field of awareness. It’s like our beautiful and complicated differences arise and to speak about them and to explore them from that place of of it curiosity and non-separation again is the is the practice. What it what this intelligence appears to be motivated to do is to break through separation in the ways that it has us captive through our thoughts, through our experience. through yeah through the assumptions that we make about who we are and who each other is.

Rufus Pollock (23:46) Now, I want to talk

Elizabeth Debold (23:48) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (23:48) a little bit about the delicacy and the question of how we continue cultivating this, which has been then your in a way your whole work. Because was you say again, you say, This is the quote from Dreyfus Kelly, the work of the reconfigurer would be so radical that people could not understand what it called them to do. And you say this was a

Elizabeth Debold (24:10) Yes.

Rufus Pollock (24:11) significant factor, this is then your words, in Cohen’s failure as a reconfigurer, because Not only did his students not understand what they were called to do, Cohen was not clear about this either. Could

Elizabeth Debold (24:21) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (24:22) and so, for example, could you say a bit, you know, you’ve mentioned before, but you say a bit about the fact that, for example, Cohen wanted to then attack the ego in a way, but which often then reinforce it. Maybe not just about Cohen, but in general, we can imagine there are practices that will kind of remove the self, but which actually reinforce it. For example. Can you say a bit more about that then? What What didn’t work and you what did Cohen misunderstand and what is maybe a general point here of like, oh it’s actually quite delicate to work out practices that cultivate this field, this emergent field of the collective.

Elizabeth Debold (25:00) Yeah, well I would I think to add that his method, maybe not the practice, but the method of engaging was one of constant humiliation. Which of course I’m trying to think of some is there another word for it?

Rufus Pollock (25:30) Well I also point out that

Elizabeth Debold (25:30) But we have

Rufus Pollock (25:31) it’s actually common in many traditions, many wisdom traditions involves things like that as ways to attack kind of attack I use the word strongly, but to undermine the ego structure. You know, that if I if I have to do a hundred thousand prostrations, it will you know, there’s but you’re saying that in if you do that it can not work. You

Elizabeth Debold (25:51) Well, it can not work, but I think it’s more than that. It

Rufus Pollock (25:54) Reinforces even.

Elizabeth Debold (25:56) it yeah, I think it’s also what is the assumption that you’re

Rufus Pollock (26:01) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (26:01) working with. So you’re working with a an assumption of separation.

Rufus Pollock (26:07) Right.

Elizabeth Debold (26:09) You’re meeting someone and you’re saying you’re separate from me. You know, you’re and you’re humiliating you’re humiliating them so that they recoil into separation and then and then you’re accusing them of being separate. and humiliating them by saying that you know, all kinds of things about them that are below standard or that show that they’re that they’re not worthy of anything. It was quite a harsh environment and one that constantly pushed and you could say, okay, I mean, and Andrew might say this, that this is the ultimate test of self-transcendence. That at those

Rufus Pollock (27:01) Yes.

Elizabeth Debold (27:02) points, that at those points of being of having a desire to be most self-protective, that point of utter self-protection because you’re feeling humiliated and ripped to shreds. That at that point to leap to something else or to surrender is a moment of spiritual transformation. But it depends on it depends on where you’re coming from. particularly as the teacher. I mean I mean that as by the teacher or by and Andrew to some extent or at some times I think held that well but mo I would say much of the time he did not and I would say that the most students around him did not did not understand the love that needs to be the foundation of a movement.

Rufus Pollock (28:09) Yeah, and I guess I’m also hearing it that they’re because that’s not just common in that tradition, there are other traditions, wisdom traditions, that take that logic. And I think what I hear is something it’s like, don’t think about the pink elephant. If I sell you stop being separate in a way, I’m reinforcing it. Like it’s like you’re gonna think about the elephant. Like if I that the

Elizabeth Debold (28:32) Right.

Rufus Pollock (28:33) re that in some cases the level can be such that there’s this kind of recall and there’s nothing left and you kind of leap to Transcending the self, but often you’ve just reinforced and kind of reinforced the very defenses and structures that you’re trying to liberate from. Okay, so

Elizabeth Debold (28:48) Right.

Rufus Pollock (28:49) what do you think let’s leave from what didn’t work? What were you learning from this and maybe not just then but over time as are more skillful ways to cultivate this field of interbeing as you’ve come to call it?

Elizabeth Debold (29:04) Well it’s what I was alluding to before. It’s that having in a deep experience of this, if you have a willingness, this would be intention, but if you have a willingness and curiosity about what is possible between us that is sincere, so that’s like basically the ground. If you’re coming in to explore this from a cynical or you know dismissive like prove it to me kind of attitude, that’s probably that most of the time doesn’t work. You’re focused on the wrong thing and what you need to be focused on is something that is actually quite subtle. that exists between us. And the more we pay attention to it, the more or give it our attention, the more it comes alive and strengthens and therefore our sensing becomes clearer. But If you have that kind of minimum level of willingness, curiosity, interest, then you can have an experience of this living field. And from that comes a desire to care for it. That there is something inherent about it. And I think this is why Cohen’s fifth tenet was care for the whole. Because there there’s something that is emergent in your experience that you feel protective of, you feel you feel love for. You

Rufus Pollock (30:58) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (30:58) feel This is this is so I can feel how delicate is it is and I can feel how precious it is. And I have some dim sense of how much this would change everything. And if you’re so if we if we start that way we’re something different is the result.

Rufus Pollock (31:32) So in terms of the your personal story after the EnlightenNext and the Andrew Cohen’s community kind of fell apart, and you and Thomas were very senior within it, or you know, partly because of Andrew’s well largely because of Andrew’s behaviour, you joined Thomas in Germany, and

Elizabeth Debold (31:52) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (31:53) there’s the point both you were kind of refining this practice, which has come to be called emergent dialogue. and ways to articulate and the field, which you are now I think calling into being or the collective field. And as you said also it’s been a it’s been a very practice led. This is not something where you’ve had a theory, it’s something where you’ve been experiencing this, refining it, and then trying to articulate it. But could you say then a little bit about that journey, that first of all that transition point and what you were trying to do? Because also many people left I think this is also a very important point, is that many times we You know, people then leave the community and like, it never but you know, actually there was a there. There was something really genuine that would that was there. And we but it’s these things are delicate. And it the particularly this collective field is quite delicate. Can you say a little more about what your path, afterwards, initially, and also what More about emergent dialogue and this kind of collective field and what your

Elizabeth Debold (33:05) Yeah. So after the organization fell apart because having a sense of betrayal that Cohen wasn’t living up to his teachings and had been playing so many power games that people were like, this is this is not what this was supposed to be. And Thomas gathered everybody who was involved in the German the German What’s it called?

Rufus Pollock (33:52) Chapter or

Elizabeth Debold (33:53) Yeah. Center.

Rufus Pollock (33:55) Group center.

Elizabeth Debold (33:57) The German center of EnlightenNext and spoke to the group. Now this at this point in time, in the last few years of EnlightenNext’s existence, there was such a struggle for money and difficulties Yeah, earning enough the magazine that was its light tower was closed. and yeah, it became people instead of doing a half day or full day retreat on Sundays and practice every morning and so forth, I think the practice in the morning continued diminished instead of two hours it was cut to one. But so that people could spend their time trying to trying to raise money through donors or whatever in order to make to make ends meet. And there was a lot of pressure put on people on leader leadership to find people to bring to the retreats to be able to earn money that way. It became it was it lost its spiritual focus. But what’s interesting about Germany is I think because of the language it was it was there was a built-in distance with Andrew. I think in some ways also because he was Jewish and it was a German center, I think it he was a little bit uncomfortable with the German context. but Thomas insisted on having they called it the Tuesday night meditation and dialogue practice. And every Tuesday night, now for about, I don’t know, it may even be twenty, twenty-five years, in the German context, people have gotten together to engage in the practice. And so it was the and I think Thomas really is the one who named it as a dialogue practice. That there is meditation and then out of the silence of meditation comes an a new form of dialogue. And he was he also protected his students, the students in his community from having to yeah. attend all the retreats and so forth when the when it was financially difficult for them and he was I mean he was he could be very tough with people but by and large he was he was managing to keep the spiritual foundation of the of the work in his community alive and active and developing. And so

Rufus Pollock (37:01) T to this is Thomas or Andrew Thomas was keeping it alive or Andrew was keeping be tough

Elizabeth Debold (37:06) Thomas.

Rufus Pollock (37:06) Thomas, yes. And so he kept and so yes, sorry, yeah. So Thomas was keeping it alive.

Elizabeth Debold (37:15) And so at the end when he asked the group do you want to continue, this was their context. Their context was I’m in a lively community with bases all around. Thomas would travel every week to a different part of Germany in order to be with them on the Tuesday night in the Tuesday night practice. He yeah, so he I mean there were there were groups all over Germany that he was nurturing and that he was he and whose presence his presence was very much yeah one of caring for this field, this practice of dialogue and the people in it. And as I said not Andrew often would ask his leaders to do things that were that were quite intense and there were people who didn’t really understand what this was about and all those complications that that created that created interpersonal difficulties with Thomas and others. But by and large there was something alive in spirit that people knew. This is real, this is happening, it’s happening between us. We don’t and at that time, I think for many people, it was we don’t understand it, but we sense it, we feel it. And I think Thomas then on his own after and what he occupied himself for the decade, decade, thirteen years after the this crash of the organization, that he became intent on discovering like what is this and how does it how does it come What philosophical perspective makes is this an expression of? And he had done a lot of work with Heidegger for his dissertation, his dissertation in philosophy, and also others, like including Ken Wilber, and basically came to understand. what this what this is as something that Heidegger was attempting to articulate, which is which is there what does it mean what is the essence of human in terms of presence, of presencing, of being but not as beings? What is what is the expression? What how do we be human in a context in a context that moves us beyond this subject-object divide?

Rufus Pollock (40:43) Can I ask a question before because I want to come to that in a moment as well. Was just what was it like for you and Thomas to go through the breakdown and kind of in a certain way keep faith with the overall direction? Because maybe many people didn’t. I’m very intrigued because often on the path, the path, the path of the spirituality, the path of those who wish to see civilization renewal, there are breakdowns, there are significant challenges. And It’s in to me personally it’s extremely inspiring that there was this kind of renewal and continuation. But what

Elizabeth Debold (41:21) Okay.

Rufus Pollock (41:21) was it like for you personally or for Thomas in that time when it did kind of fall apart and then you kind of continued?

Elizabeth Debold (41:29) Well I think

Rufus Pollock (41:32) And what helped you continue that with you know, but what was it like first and what helped you continue?

Elizabeth Debold (41:37) let’s see what was it like?

Rufus Pollock (41:41) Was it disillusioning? Did you doubt? Or were you like, No, no, it’s we’ll keep it’s all fine?

Elizabeth Debold (41:43) No. No. No, I think I think that I mean so I came to the commun to the Cohen community at the age of forty.

Rufus Pollock (41:54) Mm-hmm.

Elizabeth Debold (41:56) I had published a best selling book. I had yeah, I had my doctorate from Harvard in developmental psychology. The things that our culture says are important and of value I had seen. I had enough, I feel I had enough grounding in the world, if you if you will, that I knew that what we were doing was real. I mean I had I had some fundamental questions that I was asking of life, and I knew that this opened something up. at a level that was that was so far deeper than psychology, than activism, than politics, than academia could possibly offer. So I had no doubt. I had absolutely no doubt. It’s important to say that there were movements afoot in EnlightenNext to break into smaller units. and try to allow much more freedom to grow smaller centers or centers that met the needs of the of the context that they were in like a center in Paris and a center in Frankfurt their character has to be different.

Rufus Pollock (43:41) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (43:43) we were looking for ways to sell the main the main center in in western Massachusetts. Andrew was a little bit disconnected from all of that. I think it was mostly the senior students that were that were trying to effectuate these kinds of plans. So there was a questioning of like how do we continue and wanting to bring in some fresh air. So the fact that that Andrew in some ways failed spectacularly at the point where pressure was put on him, ended up blowing all of those plans apart. But there was a there was a track that we were that we were

Rufus Pollock (44:32) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (44:32) going on.

Rufus Pollock (44:34) Right. There was already a trajectory of this kind of evolution to some extent.

Elizabeth Debold (44:38) yet a attempting to like how to we’ve got to move. We this needs to come alive in a different way. And Thomas and I and a few others, a very few others, also wanted to give Andrew the opportunity that he gave that in my this is how I thought about it, that he blew it. I mean he blew it in terms of not living his teaching, of taking things that he had demanded of all of us and just saying, copping out, saying, I didn’t know. I think I mentioned that last time that

Rufus Pollock (45:23) What didn’t he know? Like what was an example where you asked

Elizabeth Debold (45:26) He didn’t know that he was acting out of his ego.

Rufus Pollock (45:29) Okay.

Elizabeth Debold (45:30) He didn’t know that. And this is second tenet law of volitionality. Do

Rufus Pollock (45:34) Yeah, you do you know what you’re doing, yeah.

Elizabeth Debold (45:36) you know what you’re doing? And the organization was in dire financial straits. It really was good you know, he was the leader, he’s responsible for that. That’s he volitionally caused that. It’s like I would never do that, Elizabeth. I would never and it’s like you did. You know, this you have to face. I mean I had hoped because it would have been amazing if he would have said if he would have taken this on and gone like, wow, what it what have I done? What have I done to this? What have I done to people? What have I done what have what have I been doing? If

Rufus Pollock (46:19) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (46:20) if he would have turned that around it would have been enormo it would have been extraordinary. But he did what most of us do at first and many many did and then left, which is say which is become frightened. Frightened and withdrew and yeah did those things of self-protection and so on and so forth that we had all become familiar with. But so So that I think I was I was disappointed and also angry that he failed so miserably to do what he had been pounding us to do for at least a decade. And that That seemed that was that was hard for me. Hard for me to forgive.

Rufus Pollock (47:29) And so you said in your thing, you say letting go of the enlightenment for well, so maybe sorry. So what you’re saying is it was difficult. It was a there was a disappointment and there was both this deep faith because you had encountered something, you had this previous life experience that meant you knew the value of that. You know, I’ve seen the world, it doesn’t offer things that are so much better than this or something. And while you were disappointed, you knew you wanted to keep Going down this path, Thomas and you. And

Elizabeth Debold (48:03) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (48:05) you then talk about that letting go of the enlightenment framework that Cohen used has been important to the Latmart work. Because enlightenment, and it’s your words, is a vague term that we’re referring to some state of consciousness, the shrouded mist. You know, so

Elizabeth Debold (48:19) It’s also a very individualistic paradigm.

Rufus Pollock (48:22) very individualistic paradigm. So and you said this thing, Dreyfus and Kelly argue there needs to be an articulator, something or someone that made sense of what the reconfigurer was up to and spelled it out as a paradigm incarnating their new world. And you said unwittingly this has been our project, i.e. your and Thomas’s project. We who are writing this book that’s I hope will come out at some point soon, be working to articulate the context. Historically philosophically and developmentally for this emergent human capacity to bring alive this intelligent field that holds us. We have come to understand this emergence as a developmental pathway that is a life practice for a new culture rather than a form of spiritual enlightenment. And I’m just gonna editorialize from here. This is why I feel so privileged, Elizabeth, to have met you and Thomas and the others in the community and to see the work that you’re doing because You know, and I’ve said this on other I’ve said it on other podcasts, you know, for me, even in my sometimes we need an emergence of a new culture and of a practice and that and more importantly, to we can talk as we’re blue in the face that oh look at the climate crisis, it needs us to come together in a new level, it needs us to act at a planetary level of consciousness. It’s easy to write these things, but what is the practice? You know, or it’s it it’s you know I don’t mean it’s easy, the brilliance of like John Vervaeke articulating the meaning crisis. And I know John is very engaged in too. I’m not saying he isn’t, but what are the practices? What is it we actually can do? And we need the and you know, the practice that you are describing you’ve been developing that I I’ve also experienced is a this as a developmental pathway that is a life practice for a new culture. Wow. I’m just like, wow, yes.

Elizabeth Debold (50:16) Okay.

Rufus Pollock (50:21) And what’s difficult, and you and it’s we’re trying to even I I’m you know, among many reasons trying to talk to you on this podcast and have listeners hear this, is that as you said also before, making sense of what of a reconfiguration of a culture is very difficult. When

Elizabeth Debold (50:37) Uh-huh.

Rufus Pollock (50:38) you know, when you if and I think it’s useful these historic analogies we both mentioned, but you know, there’s Christ or there’s these people going off in the wilderness in Judea or elsewhere. It’s gonna be very weird to the mainstream culture. I mean, it’s gonna be very, very alternative. I mean, in that case there were there was maybe some things around. I you know, similarly, what’s going on in the Renaissance, I mean, that is a more power-based one, but it’s still weird for a load of people. I mean you know, when you get the Quakers who are suddenly

Elizabeth Debold (51:07) Mm-hmm.

Rufus Pollock (51:08) sitting around in a circle and that the there’s been the Catholic Church, all this hierarchy, all this structure, suddenly you’re sitting in the circle as a bunch of Christian Quakers saying, Let the Lord, you know. you know, the spirit’s gonna descend on

Elizabeth Debold (51:19) For us.

Rufus Pollock (51:19) someone and you know, and there’s no leader, there’s no you know, it these are very unusual practices that are kind of very weird to the surrounding society and very difficult to articulate what’s going on. I mean often in fact and in this case it’s particular particularly so given how hyper individualized we are and ha

Elizabeth Debold (51:43) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (51:44) the way of modernity. So I w

Elizabeth Debold (51:46) And can I can I add something? Or you

Rufus Pollock (51:48) Yeah, yeah, please.

Elizabeth Debold (51:50) and people experience this and reinterpret it very much from an individualistic framework.

Rufus Pollock (51:59) Can you say what do you mean so experien they have this experience that of the kind of away

Elizabeth Debold (52:01) Yeah. So they you come into a an emergent dialogue training session or an open lab or for an interbeing open lab and you sense something in the environment, you hear people talking about that, it feels really good. It feels it feels Like someone has used the word tenderness. There’s a tenderness in the space between us. It’s like, wow, that’s wonderful. Ooh, I could just stay here in these warm waters forever. You know, just like this is this is this is so nice. I feel so good. And that’s really the end of their engagement with it in a certain way. They may come back to get hits of the good feeling, but they like being able to understand like wow, what does it mean that we’re doing this? How is it possible that this comes about? What is this sense of tenderness and coming home and belonging? I remember one woman from South America saying, I would like to invite you all home for dinner. To my house, that you can all come to my house. I wish all of you I think there were a hundred and fifty people online. This was during COVID. I want you to all come to my house and have dinner. It which is a lovely expression of, you know, I just I feel so connected to you. I feel like you’re my family. But the implications for what this is, what it means, and the further development of it, because this is just the first bit, is just getting a sense of the field. Like there is something alive between us. It affects me, I feel it. Well that’s like baby step one. But to then lean into this, and I mean that almost physically. We often do an exercise that’s about leaning in. and really exploring one’s experience in the field together, that there’s an intelligence that starts to arise like the wind. You know, you feel you you feel something that is not just you and the others in the in the in the group. You feel there’s a presence of something else. And that something else starts to you’re participating, you’re engaging, you’re available to it, but it starts to move, something starts to move that you recognize is not simply you. And you are allowing it to access you. And it synergizes the perspectives that we have. This is where the diversity and unity comes in. That out of this field and this growing sense of an intelligence that is working, what happens is that that the different perspectives that we hold somehow become start to be orchestrated or synergized in a way that you the your sense is we’re not simply doing this. There’s something else that’s here. That’s interbeing.

Rufus Pollock (55:53) Hmm. That’s in a being because you right, say from this term enlightened communication that was being used, a change in name better matched the process that we experience. So, for a time, we just referred to emergent dialogue because this emergence of a living space between happens in dialogue, evoked through language. Moreover, the dialogue itself is emergent in its nature. Now As we have learned more from the practice, we speak about interbeing as the field and capacities of this co intelligence and emergent dialogue as the practice that enables us to access and co create with that intelligence.

Elizabeth Debold (56:37) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (56:41) This better captures the experience of a field of living presence between, within and beyond us. And this shared awareness is in process developing. It is emergent. Wow.

Elizabeth Debold (56:57) Yeah, and think about all that needs to be in place for this to really to happen. Because you need a group of people, the some significant number and we don’t know how much how many that is. Is it a third, two-thirds, half, you know, five sixths of the group has to be have a level of awareness of presence? Of being present. and being it and that there is a collective presence that is more than just one’s own presence or the presence of another or the others that are in the group. It’s and be willing to be kind of a allow something to engage with oneself. that is that

Rufus Pollock (58:04) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (58:05) is beyond oneself. and that it it’s allowing we often speak about it a as a wu wei, a wu wei practice. that you’re allowing and or doing and not doing. So you’re making possible, but you’re not you’re not the simple source of the of the action. It’s a complex this is again this is again this kind of resolution of paradox and it relates to something that we were speaking about before. That Of course I see you as an individual, Rufus. I see I see your uniqueness and yet I can I can also perceive that we’re connected in something right now. there’s some way there’s something that is between us and to give that between us part credence to be curious about it to co-participate in learning from and with and but and by it is then the is then the work. So I see you and I see the I see the connectivity. I it actually becomes a part it’s not a visual it’s not a visual seeing. It’s more a sensing seeing.

Rufus Pollock (59:47) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (59:52) And then in that there’s a kind of landing. A landing and a softening and a connect and a sense of connectivity.

Rufus Pollock (1:00:10) And so Again, if I was imagining I’m a listener. You were talking about this ability sometimes that then to in this field there can be differences, but there’s ability to synthesize or not have them just disappear or submerge, but somehow something new can arise, new ways of coming together. Can you think of just one example as for today, maybe we’re coming towards the end of this session or episode, what has been an example in your experience where you felt that happen in the group? Where you know, anyway where even some thing, you know, maybe it was where do we organise an event or I don’t know, all of the things that happen in collectives where the I could imagine this being very powerful, but actually also I don’t want to say concrete but visible in the traditional most sense of visible to people listening. Can you give an example like that where that has happened a little bit?

Elizabeth Debold (1:01:21) Well I I can I one comes to mind that was very recent. there was something else. that I wanted to mention. I hope it’ll come back. If it’s if it’s important, I assume it will. but we’re right now as an organization in a in a in a tough financial spot. And we’re talking about having to wondering which wondering how to go forward. And we were meeting with consultants about this and It’s a very tense and you I could see we could there was a way in which we were it’s like no things have to be the way they are. We can’t let go of anything that we’re doing. You know, we can’t yeah, we can’t stop this, we can’t stop that. It’s all important. We you know, this is we’ve been doing this for years. We need to We need to keep this going. This everything is related, you know. And one of the consultants said, What if you started fresh? And what happened was there was there was a palpable there was a an opening in consciousness and I know I use that word but it’s a it’s how it descri it it’s how it how one senses it. Something opened up between us that there was a profound sense of freedom. Profound sense of openness to possibility. And all of a sudden, we didn’t speak about this specifically, like, well, so what’s next? But it was there was something that rose up between us that broke open this kind of clinging to the way things had to be. And And just pr it was like having it was like having the like when you’re when you’re in a stuffy room and you open a window

Rufus Pollock (1:04:04) The window.

Elizabeth Debold (1:04:05) and the pff, the air comes in. But it there was a there was an incredible confidence, confidence and sense of potential that arose

Rufus Pollock (1:04:18) Mm-hmm.

Elizabeth Debold (1:04:19) arose with this. Now, we haven’t hit the nitty gritty stage yet. But that will that will come, but it but it will be grounded in this consciousness. And there’s no there’s no you know, one member of the team was like upset about having made a mistake on some of our financial reporting. or yeah, financial analysis. She had made a mistake. And it was like that’s it there’s no blaming here. There’s no blaming there’s it it’s it does yeah, there’s a way in which respect and love and possibility just Opened.

Rufus Pollock (1:05:18) Mm. Well.

Elizabeth Debold (1:05:24) And it it’s like such a different a different foundation than is usually there.

Rufus Pollock (1:05:33) Yes. Well, I just want to say thank you so much, Elizabeth. and for listeners, this is the second episode. And I think that’s given you a taste of also Why not only is this practice in some very deep sense transformative, but also is very relevant for what we talk about in the second renaissance or just civilizational renewal, like when actually come to deep challenges we have which involve on the scale of what Elizabeth described in her organization, but almost on a civilizational scale. These things is so relevant. I don’t want to instrumentalize the practice, but I’m saying that it is of deep relevance to some of the deep polar ali polarization and moments where we’re gonna need to come together with some kind of very new solutions or very new ways of approaching challenges we face. And therefore in the say play

Elizabeth Debold (1:06:48) Can I add one thing?

Rufus Pollock (1:06:50) please add one thing.

Elizabeth Debold (1:06:51) I think this is what I wanted to bring in before, that it’s not always things get synergized into something that I mean we use the word from Heidegger that there’s an Ereignis, that things come into its own, it feels round, it feels like you know It feels like something’s been birthed that feels yeah feels right in its wholeness. There’s also the there’s also in this practice and in this work a capacity for holding tension that is incredibly important. There are times when things are too far apart and they don’t come together. But then there’s a deeper holding that becomes possible. And that is that is a kind of long-term alchemical process. You know, it’s not that okay, now we’ve got it. It’s like it’s now it’s done. But there is something that happens in just the holding. And I’ve seen that I remember there was there was a kind of friction between Thomas and one of our long term training participants and he spoke to it and held it. in a way that allowed her to sh to stay true to herself but to shift something between them and a allow something different and something new, as you were saying, to arise in the group.

Rufus Pollock (1:08:45) This field of interbeing. Well, and a term that’s very resonant with me, as I living here next to Plum Village and Thich Nhat Hanh. So I want to say for next episode, because we can see this is a si a series with Elizabeth. I think we’ll be looking at this tie between worlds and maybe going a little bit the history of separation and then what is interbeing and from that looking a little bit into the emergence and wholeness. I think that word again also just for me to resonate, that’s very interesting that I think wholeness comes up again and again. It comes up in Christopher Alexander, it comes up actually in Landmark the integrity and wholeness were this aspect of something being whole as you say, a larger wholeness that something can be part of. That is very, very intriguing. So yeah, next time we will in we’ll look at the

Elizabeth Debold (1:09:44) And we we need to talk about the imaginal.

Rufus Pollock (1:09:48) The imaginal and the sacred, which we’ll

Elizabeth Debold (1:09:50) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (1:09:51) return to. So, thank you very much.

Elizabeth Debold (1:09:53) Okay.

Rufus Pollock (1:09:54) This is episode number two. It will be part of the Over Mountains podcast series. And thank you so much, Elizabeth. It’s very, very precious and very important that you’re sharing this. Thank you so much. And I look forward to talking

Elizabeth Debold (1:10:04) Thank you, Rufus. Thank you so much.

Rufus Pollock (1:10:06) to you in the next episode.

Elizabeth Debold (1:10:09) Yeah, thank you. It’s lovely that you’re having me. I really appreciate it.

New here? Start with the three episodes we would begin with. New episodes come in our monthly email.