This site is the successor to the Second Renaissance website. Why the new name

PodcastThe Field Between UsPart 3 of 4

The Caterpillar Knows Nothing of the Butterfly: Living in the Goo

Modernity is dissolving. Something is reorganising the goo.

Series intro

This is part of a four-part series with Elizabeth Debold on interbeing and emergent dialogue.

Elizabeth Debold, Ed.D., came to the late Andrew Cohen's EnlightenNext community at forty with a Harvard doctorate and a bestselling book, and found something none of it had prepared her for: a field of shared awareness that opened between eleven women on a retreat in 1999, then between thirty men in 2001. She was thrown out five times and kept going back. When the community collapsed she and her partner Thomas Steininger, who died in 2025, spent the years since asking what that field was and how to cultivate it without a guru. Four conversations with Rufus Pollock: the story, the practice, the ideas, and where it could lead.

This episode

Elizabeth starts with the image her book starts with: in the cocoon the caterpillar becomes goo, its old cells fight the change, and it knows nothing of what it is becoming. Modernity is the caterpillar. The backlash across the world is the old cells saying no.

Then a brief history of separation: Plato’s two worlds, Christianity’s heaven and earth, Descartes finding one thing he could stand on (I think, therefore I am) and leaving everything else, including the body and, as she tells it, the barking dog, as mechanism. The freedom that bought: Galileo saying the earth moves against everything our senses tell us. The cost: Thomas in hospital, after doctors wouldn’t hear him, saying of his own experience, “It means nothing. It doesn’t count.” From there to today’s meaning crisis, Lauren Berlant’s cruel optimism, and the promises of modernity (house, soulmate, status) that no longer pay out.

Modernity got, like, kind of scooped out the in-between everywhere.

The second half is the hard part made clear. The imaginal (Corbin) is not fantasy; it is where meaning is made, and the story of Descartes and the dog, she says, was an imaginal act. Interbeing is what happens when that in-between comes alive between people: “You enter a place where one plus one equals three.” She ends by saying she has no definition, and that nobody saw this coming, which leads her to trust it more.

I was thinking today that you enter a place where one plus one equals three.

Chapters

  • 00:00A time between worlds
  • 01:05The caterpillar knows nothing of the butterfly
  • 02:30Living in the goo
  • 05:10A short history of separation
  • 10:05Descartes: "I think, therefore I am"
  • 12:35"It's my subjective experience. It means nothing."
  • 16:12What the split gave, and what it cost
  • 18:04The broken promises of modern life
  • 23:05Impasse, and the imaginal
  • 26:07Descartes, the dog, and the worlds minds build
  • 29:04Not imaginary: the source of meaning
  • 35:21When interbeing opens: one plus one equals three
  • 42:10Has the field always been there?
  • 45:23Notice the light in the room
  • 52:54"I don't have an answer"

Speakers

Elizabeth Debold, Ed.D., is a gender researcher, writer, and teacher who has spent four decades asking how women and men can grow toward freedom and equality together. She was a founding member of the Harvard Project on Women’s Psychology and Girls’ Development, co-wrote the bestseller Mother Daughter Revolution, and co-founded One World in Dialogue, a global network of people practicing deep dialogue.

Rufus Pollock is a co-founder of Life Itself, an entrepreneur, activist, and author, as well as a long-term zen practitioner.

Transcript

Rufus Pollock (00:14) Welcome Elizabeth to this ongoing series with you setting out the you know, introducing your work and Thomas’s work and the work of many colleagues around emergent dialogue and interbeing. I wanted to

Elizabeth Debold (00:28) Thank you for this.

Rufus Pollock (00:30) Yeah.

Elizabeth Debold (00:30) It it’s great to be continuing this exploration.

Rufus Pollock (00:36) So I wanted to begin where you talk about a time between worlds and this history of separation and you give this metaphor of the caterpillar and the butterfly image. Like we’re the goo, like I am looking and the old world has lost its grip, but the new one doesn’t exist yet. And what does it actually mean to live in the goo, to be in that in between? And what you mean by the goo, like first of all, maybe that metaphor of the butterfly, and then what does it actually mean for us to be living in that period?

Elizabeth Debold (01:05) I think the first sentence in that chapter is the caterpillar knows nothing of the butterfly that it will become. And I think that right there says something profound about the place that we’re in. That we don’t know what’s next. The caterpillar the caterpillar represents modernity and the world of separation and division that modernity is all about. And or th the modern mind is a mind that is that is that makes sense of things that are physical or material and that often exist in extreme binary p polarities. And by that I mean self-other, masculine feminine, mind, body, these core concepts of division that make up the modern mind, that caterpillar is going through a phase of transformation, if we’re lucky.

Rufus Pollock (02:30) and what just to set out because people may not be familiar with it, but is the metaphor of the butterfly, caterpillar to butterfly, like what happens in between, ‘cause that’s what you talk about, is the goo.

Elizabeth Debold (02:39) Uh-huh. Yeah. Yeah, so we’re in a place. We’re in a place that is like the caterpillar. At a certain point, the caterpillar in its cocoon becomes a kind of goo. It it’s its body is broken down by these imaginal cells that that will transform it into the butterfly. But it fights like crazy. The cells of the existing caterpillar fight against the this transformation that’s happening. And that’s where we are. Meaning that we don’t know what’s next. We don’t know what’s what w how to how to get beyond modernity. Most of we’re all living within it. there’s you can see the backlash across the world. All this extreme right wing movements are like the caterpillars old cells saying, No, we’re not gonna change. And And that the things that had given people hope or comfort or sense of meaning, like romance, like marriage, which is really the only thing that wealth, status, and the love of your life were the promises of modernity. And and status could be through all kinds of different things.

Rufus Pollock (04:25) Sure. It’s Mad Men. I mean, I think of the TV series Mad Men, you know,

Elizabeth Debold (04:27) Yeah. Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (04:29) and all of them are breaking down in the sixties, as it were, in that movie, you know.

Elizabeth Debold (04:33) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (04:34) I would I just want to say, so like just to say that for listeners, so this metaphor of the butterfly, the caterpillar to the butterfly, and that

Elizabeth Debold (04:41) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (04:42) we’re in that intermediary stage where the caterpillar is breaking down, modernity, capitalism, the these things are disintegrating, but we’re not you know, we don’t yet You know, modernity’s fighting like crazy, but we’re in that intermediate goo stage. That is a very powerful metaphor of where we are, that we’re in this time between worlds. Now, you keep emphasizing that an element, a major element of modernity is the separation. This

Elizabeth Debold (05:10) Mm-hmm.

Rufus Pollock (05:10) this and you give this brief history in the book, but you say you trace the history of separation from Plato through Christianity to Descartes, and the moment when the thinking substance, the res cogitans in Descartes. get split from everything else, including the body. And that created extraordinary freedoms. You talk about it like the fr the freedom of kind of conception of abstraction, but also, but was it worth it? So can you tell me a little bit about that history of separation and what were the benefits and what were the costs in a way, or you know, what was it what were the freedoms it brought and what were the things we lost?

Elizabeth Debold (05:50) Okay, so

Rufus Pollock (05:51) So first the brief history.

Elizabeth Debold (05:53) first a brief history. All right. Well starting with Plato, the sense the thing to look for is often a binary opposition. That the world is divided in into neat halves. So we have Plato’s cave and the world of ideas and pure and pure forms, that is the positive. And then we have life on earth. So there’s a duality built into this into the system of thinking at the at the core of Western thought. And if you that becomes I’m gonna do a real big jump. That becomes in Christianity heaven and earth. You know that heaven is the ideal, the world to come, what you’re striving for. And Earth is sinful, lustful, and a testing ground really. But it’s this sense of division, this sense of kind of a moral flavor put on the this these divisions where there’s the ultimate good and then the tainted which is which is our life on earth. That is a fundamental aspect of Western thought. And it eventually well it eventually b becomes a permeating thought, or way of thinking with Descartes. So I’m not doing a good job of filling in all the details. it’s too much to do that. But that The tri the the recognition th the kind of d separation of God from like God from the world. this entire that God is both all of this is God’s creation and yet God is separate from and ultimately will judge us for our behavior on earth in this testing ground. but this creation of separation as a way of thinking, as a way of being in the world. I would I would jump to D Descartes that hit his his attempt to find something that was that was strong that he felt could bear his weight, let’s put it that way. That he was he was it I mean Descartes’s meditations are in his exploration of his own mind and his and the structure of reality made him realize that he could be that he could be fooled by a demon. That there has to be some way for us to understand or know what’s true and what’s Yeah. Could yeah. People still

Rufus Pollock (10:05) We c we could be in the matrix. It could all be it could all be

Elizabeth Debold (10:11) People think that at this point these da these days that we’re in a simulation.

Rufus Pollock (10:14) Yes. But this inquiry but how what’s the one thing we still would know in Descartes is the kind of cogito ergo sum?

Elizabeth Debold (10:25) Yeah, er erg yeah, cogito ergo sum. Yeah, basically

Rufus Pollock (10:30) That’s thinking.

Elizabeth Debold (10:31) basically the only thing I have to hang on to is that I am. And I am and I know that I am because I’m thinking.

Rufus Pollock (10:42) Mm-hmm.

Elizabeth Debold (10:44) And that’s a very, very powerful thing. It liberates the mind from its rootedness in the material world in a sense. I mean it’s interesting because it’s it becomes a basis for the scientific method, which is only about Proof in the material realm or disproof in the material realm. But it’s it it’s a freedom to be able to think outside the parameters of a world that is created by God.

Rufus Pollock (11:39) you the challenge is you end up with these two substances, the res cogitans, the mind, and the res extensa, the kind of material world, things which have extension, and these are kind of profoundly separated. Is that right? Yeah.

Elizabeth Debold (11:52) Yes, and I was saying ironically, the brain becomes an extension. It’s like we this the space of truth or reality becomes thinner and thinner. Everything becomes everything becomes external.

Rufus Pollock (12:14) Right. Eventually there’ll be this problem with the mind. Like see creates this separation of mind body. But eventually, as we get more and more materialist, there’ll be this thing today where it’s like, well, even the mind doesn’t exist. It should just be collapsed onto the brain and the

Elizabeth Debold (12:29) Right.

Rufus Pollock (12:29) res extensa. There is no res cogitans. It’s just all a phenomenon of this material world.

Elizabeth Debold (12:35) Right, and the brain the brain’s cre yeah, the brain’s creates the illusion of consciousness, the illusion of being an independent or self-generating, self-creative human being. That that’s kind of a fiction. So it so in this way, like the experience of being human. in this trajectory that starts with Descartes so powerfully. The experience of being human is given less and less and less space as real. It’s just I remember when my partner was in the in the hospital and we were trying to explain to the doctor something that was going on in his experience and they wouldn’t have it. Meaning they would when they left the room, Thomas said to me, he said, It it’s my subjective experience. It’s my subjective experience. It means nothing. It doesn’t count. And that is d a devastating I mean some of this comes out of There’s the recognition that our senses are not trustworthy to be able to see what is actually true. There’s that phenomenon with Galileo and Copernicus. You know, Galileo at his trial leaving and saying, but it still moves, meaning the earth is moving, the earth is moving. our sense of that is diff is different. But that undermining of human experience that becomes more and more egregious over the centuries is a gutting of the human spirit, if you want to I mean even that term in this context sounds really sort of foolish. But the mist the mystery of life is kind of cut out. Anything sacred doesn’t it doesn’t make any sense. But living in a world that is so defined and that is so rooted in an undermining of the depth of things that make us human is creates loneliness, creates division, creates a sense of being lost. of being in a cold, dark universe with where you don’t mean anything. There’s no meaning to your life. It’s utterly random that you’re here. And that is that permeates our modern culture and in subtle and not so subtle ways.

Rufus Pollock (16:12) So you I mean you’re right that there was this extraordinary liberation. So looking back from the crises of the strangling the present, this may be hard to believe, but freeing the mind from being beholden to sense experience opened greater potential for abstract thinking, which led to new methods of observation and analysis that made modern medicine, technology, and philosophy possible. and

Elizabeth Debold (16:36) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (16:37) your point here, I think, is like the example you just gave, which is a congruent of Galileo, which is Just think how extraordinary it is to realize that the sun is not moving, but it’s the earth that’s moving. You know, it goes our entire intuitive experience is the sun is moving across the sky during the day and that we’re still, but actually we’re coming along and saying, no, no, that’s wrong. And you can see the liberation of this because that takes an incredible actual leap into this abstraction of this ability to decenter experience, immediate intuitive experience. But you’re saying there’s this also this huge cost where we in the end throw the baby out with the bathwater. You know, we have

Elizabeth Debold (17:19) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (17:19) these new powers, but we lose this contact with things. And you talk here, you say about you know words, you took the abstraction transformed our relationship to language. and we end up in language as kind of a system of mental extra abstractions. And what I wanted to come to particularly here was you also said, you also then talk about. The cost now, we to come back to the kind of goo and the time between worlds. So we can see this breakdown happening. but then what is the failure of that social imaginary? And concrete, you say, you know, the scripts and stories of modern life no longer channel our desires. And you talk about how Lauren Berlant calls it a cruel optimism. What does that look

Elizabeth Debold (18:03) Mm-hmm.

Rufus Pollock (18:04) like on the ground today? You know, what do you what do you put could you point to or you would you see people could be recognizing? of this way where the caterpillar is dissolving, where the social imaginary and just to illustrate that we’ll come to that, but the social imaginary there’s a term from Charles Taylor, but in a way the assumptions that we are drenched in, I think another phrase you’re quoting in your book,

Elizabeth Debold (18:26) Yeah, [unclear].

Rufus Pollock (18:27) the way we just see the world, for when we say the kind of worldview or social imaginary of modernity no longer is kind of working for people, what would what would you point to?

Elizabeth Debold (18:39) I would point to what John Vervaeke calls the meaning crisis. I would point to like the fentanyl problem addiction, depression. t these are these are phen phenomenally huge numbers of people that are that are that are floundering in terms of being able to f to find something in life that they’re offered that gives them that gives them hope, that gives them a sense of be purpose, gives them a sense of connection.

Rufus Pollock (19:29) And so what what kind of kind you know, for example, I think you mentioned like there’s kind of job security or status, there was marriage or romance, or the idea of the soulmate. you talked about the promises of modernity, children, the middle class home. What’s happened to those dreams in, for example, the US? Like you’re saying

Elizabeth Debold (19:49) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (19:49) that that’s sort of disintegrating those promises. What would you be pointing

Elizabeth Debold (19:52) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (19:53) to for if people were listening and you like, I really can recognize those symptoms? Because This is an amazing moment where you can suddenly see what’s kind of we’re within. We can see that we’re the caterpillar dissolving. What would you point

Elizabeth Debold (20:04) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (20:05) to of those promises not now being empty? Cruel promises.

Elizabeth Debold (20:08) Well there I I mean look at the look at the political debate in the United States. The political debate in the United States is all about this. It’s all about this. It it’s meaning that a fo that when people talk about the affordability crisis it’s like pe the people who feel that they they’ve worked hard. They’re There are many people are working two or three jobs in order to be able to maybe buy a house someday, but the ha the price of houses is just so far out of reach. young Gen Z and millennials are having less sex they’re less often in relationship. The birth rates are declining. There are all these signs of human connection or the things that were promised that somehow are failing. And people are left with n with a sense of emptiness. I don’t mean Buddhist emptiness. I mean that there Yeah yeah.

Rufus Pollock (21:32) Yes. The nihilistic emptiness. Yeah.

Elizabeth Debold (21:37) Yeah and actually nihilism is also a powerful force I think at this point. This whole This whole masculinist movement. I’m gonna I’m not gonna remember remember the names of some of the chief instigators there, but this kind of brutality in relationship, this hatred of women, I mean this whole way in which the promise that has failed you becomes the thing that you that you deride and had kind of lash out at you know, all these the fabled young men in the in their mother’s basements. You know, th this all of these phenomena are about the failure of the c the modern social imaginary to capture something to be an expression of something that means something to people, that brings them connection, love, ah meaning, and purpose.

Rufus Pollock (23:05) So yeah, you I mean you have this beautiful quote from Berlant, Lauren Berlant, where you say where she writes, We live in a state of impasse, a moment where existing social imaginaries and practices no longer produce the outcomes they once did, but no new imaginaries or practices have yet been created. Which comes back to this point of like through the kind of reconfiguring. And what that comes to

Elizabeth Debold (23:30) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (23:31) then here is like you then start to talk like about the fact that impasse can be useful however, like the neither here nor there of the in-between, it can catalyse something new. Being empty-handed brings us against the limits of what we think we can control. We are forced to not know. And this impasse invites imagination, not as an escape into fantasy, but as the exercise of a profound human creative capacity that opens to the potential of the in-between and interbeing. So, you know, this is your beautiful words here. from the upcoming book. You say then you start to talk about Henry Corbin’s concept of the imaginal and its relationship to the imagin imaginary. Can you say something about that? you know, what is the imaginal and why and what is its role here and what is its relationship to interbeing? But start with you, what is the imaginal and why is it so important in your work?

Elizabeth Debold (24:29) Well the imaginal is is everything in a certain sense. I mean it’s quite astonishing. So first of all, human development happens, and this is one of the things that Bob Kegan points out so clearly, that other developmental theorists speak about, is he he’s he sa that when you step back and you see a bigger picture. when you’re when all of a sudden the assumptions that you’re drenched in become apparent to you. You begin to see them. So the imaginal is the recognition that the human mind and is creates fictions of the real that it lives through. That’s that and This capacity of the of the human mind to create and open to different dimensions of reality is a is a fundamental aspect of being human that has been overlooked and dismissed in modernity. Now next step is to by that by yeah.

Rufus Pollock (25:59) W what just a sec can you just help me g if you could give me almost like that sentence illustration, maybe not a definition of just the imaginal Yeah, okay. Yeah.

Elizabeth Debold (26:07) Well let’s go let’s go back to friend Descartes. Let’s go back to friend Descartes. So he he’s living in a world where he imagines we would say imagines demons. That’s not an imagination for him. That’s reality. Once he as he as he asserts th that I think therefore I am. and says, okay, this thinking subject that I am make means that everything else is not is not is not a being. So he has these vivisection experiments that he does with dogs, where he cuts the dogs open and he says that’s not the that barking and sc and howling and screaming is not is meaningless. It’s not about pain. This is th these These are little these are the little mechanical barkings of a of a non a non sentient being. These are like little robots. Now how we we’re appalled by that. That he’s cutting open living dogs and they’re barking and he’s saying that they’re just the capacity of the mind to create structures of reality is phenomenal. Is phenomenal.

Rufus Pollock (27:46) is just so I’m getting it here. What you’re pointing out is that well, so just to say to quote you for your but where you’re quoting Tom Cheetham, you’re saying the imaginal refers to the world intermediary between sensation and intellect. The imaginal world is the realm of the symbolic, the alchemical, the visionary, the wonderful. The imagination is its mediating function. But what I’m getting here in the example of the dog is in the sense that Descartes this idea that a dog is just a machine and not feeling anything. is actually in this world of the imaginal. And this imaginal is very powerful because it’s

Elizabeth Debold (28:17) Yes.

Rufus Pollock (28:19) intervening between these sh these noises the dog are making and what we make and what Descartes makes it mean. So in one world it would be that dog is an incredible pain, we’re hurting the dog. But in another world where we’ve made a story that the dog is a machine and these are just the mechanical sounds the machine makes. And so what you’re saying is that place where Descartes makes up a s has a story or an Is the imaginal when you say a story is too little, y a whole structure and kind of vision and a making sense of sensation in the world. But that what that imaginal is also alive in some sense. It this is the connec maybe you could say more, it’s not just well, mental constructs, but it’s somehow even more than that in some way.

Elizabeth Debold (29:04) Yeah. Yeah, well well, it’s our entire culture is an imaginal like that like Charles Taylor’s social imaginary or cruel optimism. That this entire the entire way that we understand reality is an imaginal act or is of is taking place at the imaginal level. So the imaginal is a dimension of reality and it has a direction to it because it moves from the concrete and physical which is what Western culture has kind of invested so much in. But that investment is an investment in a shared reality that is that is imaginal. And that doesn’t mean imagined. That doesn’t mean that it’s that it is imaginary. There’s a difference between a the term imaginal is is pretty horrible, I would say, because it it’s so easily because in mod modernity the imagination or the imaginary are yeah fantasy, it’s silly, it’s playful, it’s yeah, it’s Pixar, Disney, it’s yeah, it’s unreal. But

Rufus Pollock (30:47) In a way you’re saying it’s everything, at least in how we make meaning exist in the world. It th this is the imaginal.

Elizabeth Debold (30:54) The imaginal is the way is the source of meaning.

Rufus Pollock (30:59) Right, because you say this, you say and again to quote you, the imaginal is in between, encompassing webs of connectedness that generate meaning. Meaningfulness is not simply cognitive, a proposition or a bit of knowledge. It is existential. Humans are meaning makers, motivated to make coherent sense of things, and intrinsic to human consciousness is a leaning or reaching into the not yet, the not known. A self-transcendence driven by a longing for wholeness that doesn’t just happen in a void. The experience is of being pulled by something greater than oneself, that self is seeking to be known. So I’m also hearing that this that this is also what starts to point towards interbeing. It’s that there’s

Elizabeth Debold (31:42) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (31:43) that there’s an aliveness to the imaginal. It’s not simply and it’s not simply created by human consciousness or something, or you know, it there’s a dark it’s more that, you

Elizabeth Debold (31:52) There yeah.

Rufus Pollock (31:54) know, rather we participate in it.

Elizabeth Debold (31:56) Yeah, there’s a there’s a co-participation between this increasingly subtle and increasingly sacred or divine set levels or dimensions of reality that act to pull us into in into the recognition and meaningfulness of new dimensions of reality, which is unbelievable. And I don’t mean that that’s it’s unbelievable that it’s not to be believed, but it’s extraordinary. K Henry Corbin depends or ha has gotten a lot of his ideas or the foundation for his ex exploration of the creative imagination and the human role in developing t co-developing with this these dimensions of reality. new potentials, new possibilities and so forth from Iranian Sufism. And it’s in other systems of knowledge and sacred you know, sacred unfolding, or in Iranian Sufism, there’s some of the clearest explanations and openings of what this imaginal dimension is. And again, it is not imaginary. Unfortunate choice of words, but what to what to do. But it’s not imaginary. It is it is a reality that we live in and it’s pulling us. It’s pulling those of us who are who are questioning and open to the recognition of more subtle dimensions of meaning.

Rufus Pollock (34:17) And w because you y i you say here opening to the imaginal is a re enchantment of the world. Corbin spoke

Elizabeth Debold (34:27) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (34:27) of the imaginal in specific ways, ratio scholarship and the depth of engagement with Sufism. However, once we open the doors, how the imaginal will appear to us after these five hundred years of individualism, or even a thousand or more, five hundred years of individualism and materialism is unknown. But it is unlikely to bring us back to a pre-modern animism or world filled with angels and demons guided by dogma’s hand. Perhaps these symbols and archetypes will be in re-interpreted or expanded in this time between worlds. The work is to rehabilitate imagination, reclaim the power of creativity of the in-between. Interbeing provides a ground for taking this step. So I want to come to interbeing. Because I think this is in a way, is the imaginal, like in one way the imaginal is going to show up. I mean it Not that interbeing represents it, but there’s a deep connection, isn’t there, with interbeing? And so first

Elizabeth Debold (35:21) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (35:21) of all, just straight to it, what is interbeing? Not maybe the theory, the experience. What actually happening when it opens?

Elizabeth Debold (35:34) What happens when it opens is that one feels One feels the presence of something that is beyond oneself and beyond the group as a whole. That one feels that one has insights that one has not had before, that one is drawn into a process of sense making. that re reveals new structures of thought that enables us to actually think together in ways that are that take us that are self-transcendent, that take us beyond our individualism and allow us to create Create form, create insight that is that is emergent from between us rather than simply within one’s own mind. So what hap so there’s a sense of opening, a sense of being in a different, a collective presence. I was I was thinking today that you enter a place where one plus one equals three. So there’s me here, there’s you and there’s the there’s that place in between that is that is alive and responsive and it comes to us together. It’s the beginning of what we call co-consciousness. that we are like at its depth as far as we’ve exp ex explored it or seen it working th thus far is it has an autopoiesis to it. And it also it is it is moving us into a capacity to share and work with a an overarching k s a synergizing consciousness that in which we are we begin to think together

Rufus Pollock (38:29) Yes. I mean y you write, I think again in your most succinctive interbeing where a living collective intelligence becomes self aware through us and his presence

Elizabeth Debold (38:41) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (38:41) through emergent dialogue. Interbeing brings the in-between, the imaginal, alive again. I mean I almost have this metaphor in my mind or this vision of it’s like in modernity we became like r asteroids in space, no like These like cold, dark things with this a kind of oceans of nothingness between us. But in fact, there’s this kind of field there the whole time, like you know, just like this gravity actually is pervading the space between us. And but we’ve but it’s like we’ve not stopped listening for it or discovering. So there’s this living and it’s something more than that. That the field is not just kind of passive, it’s alive. That’s why I keep hearing you say there’s it’s a

Elizabeth Debold (39:26) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (39:27) living. Collective intelligence, which is becoming self aware through us.

Elizabeth Debold (39:34) Yeah, there’s there and that that’s always a profound moment in a in a in an emergent dialogue, which is the practice of interbeing. and that is there’s a point where enough people become aware that there’s something happening or that there is this that this field has ha is is not empty, it’s living, that there’s an aliveness there. That when enough people and there I don’t know what enough means. I don’t know if it’s a third, I don’t know if it’s a half, but when this happens there’s a shift and s and there’s a shift in the space in between that the majority of participants sense and experience. that powers it to synergize between us because that’s it’s part of its function. So thus far that seems to be one of its main capacities is that it is able to synergize our perspectives so that so that we it i it opens up something new that had not been seen before.

Rufus Pollock (41:11) And you say, I think this is also an important point, which is you say this shared imaginal presence of interbeing is intermediate between the physical and the primary real ground, which Buddhists call emptiness, which is ungraspable and knowable. One is present to the imaginal, not the absolute. So I think this is also an important point that this field of interbeing that we can through emergent dialogue, one can start to sense into one can lot in a way is flowing is between us, beyond us, throwing through us, and is and is but more almost becoming self aware through us as you write. It’s not the same

Elizabeth Debold (41:50) Yes.

Rufus Pollock (41:51) as the it’s it the, you know, emptiness or the ground of being. It I think this is very significant when you come back to this idea of the kind of evolutionary arc of humanity of the caterpillar becoming the butterfly, because in a sense the absolute ground is always there. But there’s this

Elizabeth Debold (42:09) Right.

Rufus Pollock (42:10) shift you’re saying from this great period of individual individuation through modernity to this shift back to the when we’re sensing something. Can you say more about that? And I and I have all kinds of questions. Was like, was the was the field always there? And this we’ve forgotten to listen to it? Did people sense it before modernity? People have obviously some people have still sensed it during modernity. It’s always there. Yeah, I have all these kind of questions, but how yeah, just

Elizabeth Debold (42:35) Well it it’s interesting a and w we we’re we are exploring the question often, i is it always ha has it always been there? Is it always there? Because our experience is that this is this is something that you could say switches on when humans are together in and and becoming aware of the vitality of the space between us. So it does the it its potential, the potential for it may have existed before, but it also requires it requires our individuation. It requires us to be the develop the self-developed human beings that we are because one makes a choice and ongoingly makes a choice in the dialogue process to put aside you have to be developed enough to put aside your own agenda to put aside the story that you really just want to tell because it just came to mind and you th you it’s related. it requires our capacity to be self-reflective and hold the context. And without that, it’s it do it doesn’t it doesn’t work. We’re just in our individual mind. Has this existed before? Well you could say that tribal cultures had something that was that was in some ways similar, that there was there was but there is not a difference between inner and outer. That from what we understand and w that the recognition in many tribal cul cultures of depth of the sacr sacred dimensions and so forth are Th there’s not there’s not the individuated person observing this th this interior world of like the plant medicines and so forth. It’s not a separate it i that would be all encompassing. Does that make sense?

Rufus Pollock (45:23) Yes. And you give this example again in the also in the book of for people to grasp what you’re getting at when you talk about, you know, the interbeing is the living presence of the space between. Again, quoting you even more precisely, interbeing is the space between becoming self aware through us. We awaken to interbeing as it emerges through us. But you give this example of light. Could you say a

Elizabeth Debold (45:50) Mm-hmm.

Rufus Pollock (45:50) bit about that? You give this example of like Becoming aware of light in the same way this almost unnoticed presence of the in-betweenness, this th of the of interbeing, which is often we’re just not even noticing it, but it’s there if we wish if we bring our attention to it. Could you say a little bit about that example?

Elizabeth Debold (46:06) What yeah, well the first thing I want to say is I think it’s also remarkable when you when you from this perspective when you look back at modernity and you think like self-other, what is where’s the sharpness of the boundary? That there is nothing that spans self and other. There’s nothing that spans mind and body, even though you’re it’s one organism. That these divisions are kind of absolute. They cut reality. and I find that in incredibly im important. it’s if I if I say to you, notice the light in the room and like what you immediately have a different sense of awareness. of light. You don’t know what light is ne necessarily. I mean maybe you know some equations and things that properties of light and interesting found out recently that light d doesn’t need a medium to go through. It is itself the medium that it goes through. but i it it’s you’re in All of a sudden it it’s like there’s a there’s like a warmth or a recognition. So it’s all around you. This light is all around you. You look outside and you s you see it’s the same it’s slightly less bright in here than it is outside, but you have a sense of of something rather than something being absent which it was before. There’s a sense a sense that it makes that becomes part that becomes a kind of awareness.

Rufus Pollock (48:30) you’re saying this is an analogy with our awareness of the imaginal and the collective field, in the sense that it’s unnoticed,

Elizabeth Debold (48:36) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (48:37) that just like light which is kind of actually pervading the space around us, is there all the time and yet unnoticed. If we bring our attention to the field between, the in-between, ah we begin to notice.

Elizabeth Debold (48:54) Yeah, and it and it has it has qualities.

Elizabeth Debold (49:00) It both the in between of interbeing has qualities, but also light has qualities. You can be in a space that has that where the light is very cool. Like I think that m on my screen m my the light in the room that I’m in seems much more cool than where you are, Rufus. That our are somehow reality has become thicker. The reality of light has become more tangible. That’s the power of a w human awareness. That human awareness when it when it lands on something, has in some ways yeah, has this effect of kind of an opening. Or a An expansion. Because we’re not we’re not we’re not simply in our own mind world. We’re now all of a sudden engaging with that which is in between.

Rufus Pollock (50:24) Mm.

Elizabeth Debold (50:27) And that’s yeah, th the point about self other mind body, this kind of absolute cutting. It’s like it’s it modernity got like kind of scooped out the in between everywhere. And what interbeing is actually part of i is doing is it’s reconnecting us to a broader and wider and more subtle dimension of life.

Rufus Pollock (51:08) So I think this is a great moment that to complete with a sense of what interbeing is, a sense a palpable sense of it. I think this analogy of light that often unnoticed but ever present is very, very powerful. And you know, I think there are many questions or things to explore next time. in particular. around emergence and wholeness and trans individuation and the new social imaginary. I think what for me, just to kind of make a second Renaissance connection, is that

Elizabeth Debold (51:44) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (51:45) one is what are what is something that’s gonna emerge? We need a new a new social imaginary. And one aspect is that we know is we need to go somehow beyond individualism to something here like interbeing. We need a new field of collective intelligence. And we need practices, not just the idea of it, because that can be very modernity of just another idea of something, but the actual practice and the way to sense it. And I think this is this is like a profound aspect of what’s coming. of you know, why I’m so when I encountered your work, Elizabeth, and I know you’re building on the work of many others, and y we’ve discussed even of the work of the community of Andrew Cohen and others who’ve come out of that, but even before that, I just think this This is really, really profoundly important to the renewal, the civilizational renewal that we’re

Elizabeth Debold (52:40) Yeah.

Rufus Pollock (52:40) coming to. And in our next episode, I think we can look forward to you sharing more about what you see as a coming social imaginary and what the kind of emergence that’s possible out of these practices. for today, is there anything you want to say in closing before we complete this episode?

Elizabeth Debold (52:54) Yeah. Yeah, there is something that I’d like to say and that is if you simply ask me what is interbeing, I don’t have an answer for that. And I think, and it’s again, what you’re reading and what I’ve written is my attempt to give context to what you just articulated, because that’s also my sense. It’s like, wow, this is not on I’ve said this before, this is not on our charts of development. This is not something that anyone saw coming, which leads me to have to trust it more. It’s like this came out of as we spoke before, of out of a certain kind of spiritual inquiry and a recog an ability to perceive at a at a more subtle level. that opened something up. And I’m in the last, I guess, s maybe seventeen or twenty years. I mean we’ve been doing this for something like thirty years, but in the last maybe dozen years or so to really like what is the context that makes this that can give the unders an understanding of the significance of this movement in c in human consciousness. This potential transformation. And we I a small group of senior practitioners and I were reading this chapter that you’re that you’re referring to, Rufus, last night. And It’s like The amazing thing about this is anyone who is willing to engage with this is actually participating in creating a new social imaginary, an a new a new reality because this is this is in process in emergence. It is not something that is done. It’s only beginning. I mean we are just we are just scratching the surface of what is opening up here. And that is that means that all of us who are looking for something that is a new way forward, that this has s so many of the hallmarks of that which is will get us beyond goo. it will allow us to start walking in not in goo anymore, but still in the unknown, but also embracing the mystery that this is this is pointing to.

Rufus Pollock (56:25) Well. Thank you so much, Elizabeth. And I think you’re s yeah, so

Elizabeth Debold (56:29) You’re welcome, Rufus.

Rufus Pollock (56:32) resonant. Well listeners, until the next episode where we’ll explore deeper.

Elizabeth Debold (56:37) Okay.

New here? Start with the three episodes we would begin with. New episodes come in our monthly email.