This site is the successor to the Second Renaissance website. Why the new name

Blog

The Field Between Us

A collective awakening no map predicted, and the practice behind it.

Elizabeth Debold, Ed.D., came to the late Andrew Cohen’s EnlightenNext community at forty with a Harvard doctorate and a bestselling book, and found something none of it had prepared her for: a field of shared awareness that opened between eleven women on a retreat in 1999, then between thirty men in 2001. She was thrown out five times and kept going back.

When the community collapsed she and her partner Thomas Steininger, who died in 2025, spent the years since asking what that field was and how to cultivate it without a guru. Four conversations with Rufus Pollock: the story, the practice, the ideas, and where it could lead. All four are out now.

The series arc

  1. The danger and the discovery: losing the sacred; a girl of sixteen, a brutal teacher, eleven women, a collapse.
  2. The practice: what the breakthrough was made of, why humiliation can’t produce it, Tuesday nights in Germany, what interbeing is.
  3. The ideas: modernity as caterpillar turning to goo, the history of separation, the imaginal, what the field feels like.
  4. Where it leads: trans-individuation, Heidegger’s fourfold in a real decision, a second Axial Age, and Thomas.

Part 1: Thrown Out Five Times

A poem at sixteen, a tough teacher, and something real.

And he said: This is like talking to one woman with eleven heads.

Elizabeth’s forthcoming book opens with Hölderlin: where there is danger, a saving force also grows. Rufus asks about the danger first. Her answer: Western culture has lost any sense of the sacred, and you can see it in the licence to be cruel. From there: Descartes and animals as machinery, Charles Taylor’s buffered self, her forester brother looking at a 500-year-old redwood and seeing lumber, and Kegan’s self-authoring self as both achievement and trap.

Then her story: at sixteen, a poetry assignment the night before it was due, and everything became one. Feminism, Harvard, a bestselling book, and the feeling that none of it went deep enough. At forty she meets Andrew Cohen, who says he wants to bring a group of women to enlightenment together. On a retreat in France in 1999 eleven women discover their fears are the same, something bursts, and Cohen says it is like talking to one woman with eleven heads. She also describes his tough methods, the five expulsions, and the afternoon fifty students walked out when he said “I didn’t know.” Why stay? “There was something real here.”

Go to the episode page, with chapters and the full transcript. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or iHeartRadio.

Part 2: How Eleven Women Broke Through Separation

Humiliation reinforces the self. Curiosity opens the field.

It was a liberation into each other. Not an individualistic liberation. It was like a landing home together.

Rufus asks what practices produced the 1999 breakthrough. Elizabeth’s answer: the context was dialogue, though nobody named it then. What were the eleven women doing when it happened? Talking. They described the thing that cut them off when they met, someone called it an electric car window, they all recognised it at the same instant and burst out laughing, and the windows were down. You become more yourself, not less.

She explains why humiliation fails on its own terms: you push someone into separation, then accuse them of being separate. What works is sincere curiosity about what is possible between people, and care for what shows up. Then Germany: Thomas Steininger’s Tuesday night meditation and dialogue, kept going for twenty or twenty-five years and across the collapse. Why they dropped the word enlightenment, what a newcomer feels first, and a tense meeting about money where a consultant asked “What if you started fresh?” and something opened.

Go to the episode page, with chapters and the full transcript. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or iHeartRadio.

Part 3: The Caterpillar Knows Nothing of the Butterfly

Modernity is dissolving. Something is reorganising the goo.

Modernity got, like, kind of scooped out the in-between everywhere.

Elizabeth starts with the image her book starts with: in the cocoon the caterpillar becomes goo, its old cells fight the change, and it knows nothing of what it is becoming. Modernity is the caterpillar, and the backlash across the world is the old cells saying no. Then a brief history of separation, from Plato’s two worlds to Descartes and the barking dog, what the split gave us, and what it cost: Thomas in hospital, after doctors wouldn’t hear him, saying of his own experience, “It means nothing. It doesn’t count.”

The second half is the hard part made clear. The imaginal is not fantasy; it is where meaning is made. Interbeing is what happens when that in-between comes alive between people: “You enter a place where one plus one equals three.” She ends by saying she has no definition, and that nobody saw this coming, which leads her to trust it more.

Go to the episode page, with chapters and the full transcript. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or iHeartRadio.

Part 4: Earth, Sky, Mortals, Gods

What Are We Standing On? Life After Individualism

A dialogue doesn’t take place in me or in you. It takes place between us.

Rufus opens with Kegan’s spiral of balance between separateness and connection, and Elizabeth names the next turn: trans-individuation, integration without losing individuality. Touching it, she says, calls you to your knees, not in a servile way, but in awe. Then the most practical stretch of the series: how a small group would decide something hard, worked through Heidegger’s fourfold of Earth, Sky, Mortals and the Divinities. “We are the fourfold.”

Then the big claim, which she keeps conditional: the first Axial Age made us individuals; if this takes hold it could be the second, and small groups set the template. She closes on Thomas, writing the book as he was dying, with Heidegger as his thinking partner. “Our partnership is still very much alive.”

Go to the episode page, with chapters and the full transcript. Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts or iHeartRadio.

EnlightenNext was one of the most important recent communities of our time, and shrouded in mystery; this is a senior member telling it straight, toughness included.

Read more